Photoshop Quiz: Ann Taylor: Misplaced Thumbs

This week the image below which was found on Ann Taylor went viral for what people think are misplaced thumbs. Cast your vote below as to whether you think those thumbs are a disaster or not.

I think those thumbs are


Leave a comment as to why you voted the way you did.

  • scottro

    The thumb is fine. It’s what it’s growing out of that concerns me.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lightstriker-Stormyhahaha/1046633734 Lightstriker Stormyhahaha

    Its just that the thumb is so much more brightly lid than the arm and the low pixelated resolution. 

    Otherwise that’s her penis.

  • Mac Conin

    Two thumbs up for this thumb

  • Helen

    You can see in the thumbnail of the reverse view that her arm is hanging behind her back! So a definite fail

    • Bburg

      Yeah, that makes sence! Shes probably unable to move her arms, just like my tin girlfriend. 

      Btw a bit weird, yes, but not necessarily ps related imo.

  • Vern

    It’s an optical illusion. In the close up you can see the angle of her wrist is turned towards the front. luv vern

  • http://www.facebook.com/gabi.garcez Gabriela Garcez

    I’m terrified of  these models. If they look like that with photoshop, I can only imagine how’d they look like without

    • http://www.www.psdisasters.com Vernon

      I haven’t seen you in the comments in a long time. Welcome back!

  • Chresmologue

    I’m not 100% sure this is a PSD; but whether it is or not, letting a weird, ugly mess like this make it into the online catalog is a disaster of SOME sort — and given that two minutes with Photoshop could have fixed it, I guess that makes it a PSD whether it is one or not, if you follow me.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lightstriker-Stormyhahaha/1046633734 Lightstriker Stormyhahaha

    nice new format, except you wiped 2-3 days of comments. 

    • http://www.www.psdisasters.com Vernon

       It will be back. We’re moving to WordPress at the moment so we are fixing up our backend and integrating a bunch.

  • Fj

    Judging by the outline of her hand in that pocket, if that is her thumb she had it broken just for this pose.